The Chief Complaint, No. 4: The Pay Cut Nobody Voted For
Share
A family doctor who still owns her practice, on who owns yours. For anyone who has been a patient, sat beside one, or worked the shift.
The Complaint
In January, Medicare cuts the base rate it pays your doctor for nearly every visit and procedure. No one voted this year to cut it. A one-time raise runs out, and the 2015 law underneath it adds almost nothing back.
In 2015, Congress passed MACRA, the law that sets how Medicare's physician payments grow. It fixed those updates in advance, with no link to what it costs to keep a practice open:
- 2020 to 2025: the update written into the law is 0%, six years running.
- July 4, 2025: Congress passes a one-time 2.5% increase, for 2026 only.
- 2026 onward: the law's own update is 0.25% a year for most doctors, 0.75% for those in qualifying alternative payment models.
- November 4, 2026: Medicare finalizes 2027 rates. The one-time 2.5% expires.
- 2027, as finalized: the base rate falls 2.31% for most doctors and 1.83% for those in qualifying alternative payment models.
Those numbers come from Medicare's own fact sheet on the final rule, which takes effect January 1, 2027. In July, Medicare had proposed smaller cuts: 1.68% and 1.19%.
Rent did not hold still for six years. Neither did payroll, malpractice coverage, or the price of a vaccine fridge. A practice can absorb that for a while. Then it sells.
The doctors say so themselves. In the American Medical Association's survey, 42.2% of physicians worked in private practice in 2024, down from 60.1% in 2012. Among physicians whose practices were sold, the reason cited most often was to negotiate higher payment rates with insurers. A practice that cannot raise its prices joins something bigger that can.
That is how consolidation happens in a town like yours. Not with a takeover. With a payment rate that slips a little every year until the doctor who knows your name signs. After that, someone else sets the schedule, the visit length and where your referral goes.
The Chart
This week: LOW OVERHEAD, a hojicha roasted green tea powder, stone milled and naturally low in caffeine. Toasted cereal and a little umami. Named for the only way an independent practice stays open.
The Order
Ask your own doctor one question at your next visit: who owns this practice now? If the answer is still "I do," tell them you noticed.
Rounds
Has a practice you loved been bought, merged or closed? What changed the first year after?
If you work in healthcare: when did you last see a raise that kept up with your rent?
Reply. First names only, with permission, in a future issue.
Sign-out
I am a family physician in a county with few independent practices left, and I own one of them. Direct Primary Care is how I chose to practice. It is what I personally advocate for, and it is the only reason a coffee company with a cross on the cup exists.
To everyone lighting lamps for Diwali this Sunday, and to everyone working through it: may the light find you.
Despite it all, we're still here.
Maryal
Sources: Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act of 2015 (MACRA), Public Law 114-10 · H.R. 1, Public Law 119-21, July 4, 2025 (one-time 2.5% increase for 2026) · Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, CY 2027 Physician Fee Schedule Final Rule fact sheet, November 4, 2026 · American Medical Association, Physician Practice Benchmark Survey, June 24, 2025 · AMA, Physician Practice Characteristics in 2024 (reasons practices were sold).